The Stories We Choose to Care About
A Strange Pattern You Start to Notice
If you pay attention long enough, you start seeing a pattern in how compassion works in our culture.
Not compassion itself — people absolutely care. That’s not the issue.
The strange part is who we care about and when we decide to care.
You’ll see a video online of an elderly man delivering food late at night. Someone films him struggling to walk back to his car after dropping off a DoorDash order. The video goes viral. The local news runs the story. A GoFundMe gets set up.
That double standard didn’t appear out of nowhere. It reflects the deeper social divide explored in The Culture of the Haves and the Have-Nots: A Mirror of Human Flaws.
Within days, strangers donate tens of thousands of dollars.
People share the story with captions like:
“This shouldn’t be happening in America.”
And they’re right.
But then you drive down the street and see something else.
A mother standing outside a gas station with two young boys.
They’re holding a cardboard sign asking for help.
Cars drive by.
No camera.
No viral video.
No fundraiser.
Just another day of people looking the other direction.
And if you’re honest with yourself, the question starts to creep in:
Why did one story trigger compassion while the other triggered suspicion?
The answer has less to do with suffering… and more to do with the story surrounding that suffering.

The DoorDash Driver and the Mother at the Gas Station
The viral DoorDash driver story fits a cultural script people immediately recognize.
You see an elderly man still working.
Still trying.
Still hustling.
There’s something deeply emotional about that image.
Most people immediately think the same thing:
“That could be my grandfather.”
The man becomes a symbol of perseverance.
So when donations start flowing, it feels like justice. Like the community is stepping in to fix something that shouldn’t be happening.
Now compare that with the mother standing at the gas station.
She’s not captured in a dramatic viral moment.
There’s no camera zooming in on her struggle.
No heartwarming background music.
No news anchor narrating her story.
Just a woman with two kids asking for help.
And suddenly people start asking questions.
Where’s the father?
Why isn’t she working?
Is the story real?
The same society that opened its wallet for the elderly driver suddenly becomes skeptical.
Not because the need is smaller.
But because the story doesn’t fit the narrative we like to reward.
This same tension shows up when public compassion collides with real-world inequality, especially in When Wealthy-Speak Meets Homeless Reality: A Conversation Across 2 Worlds.
We Don’t Just See Suffering — We Judge It First
There’s an uncomfortable truth hiding in situations like this.
Our culture doesn’t respond to suffering equally.
We respond to deserving suffering.
For centuries, Western societies have divided struggling people into two categories:
The deserving poor
and
The undeserving poor.
The deserving poor are people who appear to be doing everything “right.”
They are:
- elderly workers
- veterans
- disabled individuals
- people working multiple jobs
They fit the moral narrative we’ve been taught since childhood.
Work hard.
Be responsible.
Keep pushing.
If hardship still finds you after that, people feel safe offering compassion.
Because helping you reinforces the cultural belief that effort matters.
But if someone’s situation is more complicated — unemployment, homelessness, addiction, unstable housing — something changes.
Instead of empathy, people start looking for explanations.
They start looking for blame.
Social Media Has Supercharged This Pattern
In the past, these judgments happened quietly in everyday life.
Now social media amplifies them.
Platforms reward content that produces strong emotional reactions.
Stories that go viral almost always follow the same structure:
- A clear hero
- A visible struggle
- A satisfying resolution
The elderly DoorDash driver fits perfectly into this formula.
Hardworking man struggles → internet finds out → community helps.
It’s emotionally satisfying.
It gives people the feeling that the world still works the way it’s supposed to.
But situations like homelessness rarely fit that narrative.
There’s no simple ending.
No clear moment where everything gets fixed.
And because those stories are messy, uncomfortable, and unresolved, they rarely go viral.
Psychologists call this the “Identifiable Victim Effect.”
People respond much more strongly to a single visible story than to widespread suffering.
Research from Carnegie Mellon University shows that emotional responses to suffering drop dramatically when the problem becomes statistical rather than personal.
When people see one person struggling, empathy spikes.
When they hear about millions struggling, the brain disconnects.
Source:
https://www.cmu.edu/news/stories/archives/2011/april/april13_identifiablevictim.html
Why Helping Workers Feels So Good
Helping someone who is clearly working activates something powerful in our cultural psychology.
It confirms the belief that many people desperately want to hold onto:
Hard work should be rewarded.
So when people donate money to someone who is still grinding despite hardship, the act of giving feels morally clean.
It feels like fairness.
It feels like encouraging the values society wants to believe in.
But helping someone who isn’t visibly working creates uncertainty.
The story becomes complicated.
Maybe there are medical issues.
Maybe there are childcare barriers.
Maybe there are housing problems.
Maybe the person lost a job they depended on.
Suddenly the situation forces people to confront a bigger question:
What if the system itself isn’t working the way we think it is?
That’s a much harder conversation.
The Hidden Barriers We Don’t See
One reason people misjudge poverty is because many of the barriers are invisible.
For example:
Childcare costs in the United States often rival rent payments.
According to Child Care Aware of America, the average annual cost of childcare can exceed $10,000 per year.
Source:
https://www.childcareaware.org
Without childcare, holding a full-time job becomes extremely difficult for single parents.
Housing instability creates another barrier.
When people are living in vehicles, couch surfing, or moving between shelters, basic things like keeping a job become exponentially harder.
Even transportation can collapse someone’s stability.
A single car repair can cost thousands of dollars. Without reliable transportation, many people can’t get to work.
These are the types of structural problems that rarely appear in viral videos.
But they shape millions of lives.
Why This Pattern Matters
The problem with selective compassion is not that helping individuals is wrong.
Helping the DoorDash driver was a beautiful act of community.
The real issue is what happens to the suffering that never goes viral.
For every viral story that raises thousands of dollars, there are millions of people struggling quietly without attention.
People working low-wage jobs.
Families sleeping in vehicles.
Workers one medical bill away from financial collapse.
But those stories don’t come with emotional music or dramatic footage.
So they disappear into the background noise of everyday life.
And when suffering stays invisible, it becomes easier to pretend it isn’t happening.
The Bigger Cultural Blind Spot
What situations like this reveal is something deeper about how modern society processes hardship.
We don’t just respond to suffering.
We filter it through a moral story first.
If someone’s struggle proves they’re hardworking, disciplined, and deserving, empathy flows.
If their situation is messy, complicated, or uncomfortable, many people look away.
Not because they’re cruel.
But because the story challenges the cultural beliefs they rely on to make sense of the world.
And when kindness disrupts a system built around distance, control, and judgment, it creates the kind of friction described in Why the System Hates Your Kindness: The Radical Friction of Unmanaged Care.
The Question Worth Asking
The next time you see a viral story about someone struggling, pay attention to what makes the story compelling.
Is it the severity of the need?
Or the fact that the story fits a familiar narrative about hard work and perseverance?
And then ask yourself something even more uncomfortable.
How many people are struggling just as much — or more — without the benefit of a camera pointed at them?
Because the truth is…
the people most in need are often the ones who never make it into the story at all.
Here are more articles to read:
- The Real Wealth of Having Less: 4 Freedoms You Can’t Buy
- The Silent Heat Wave: Why Your Rising Utility Bill Is a Community Crisis in Disguise
- They Didn’t Break the System… But They’re Telling You to Fix It
- 100 Towns · Part 1
- We Can’t Afford to House Americans, but We Can Spend $495 Million to Lock People Up? What the Fuck Is Wrong With Our Priorities?
Related reading · When Wealthy-Speak Meets Homeless Reality: A Conversation Across 2 Worlds · Why the System Hates Your Kindness: The Radical Friction of Unmanaged Care